Is Apple going the way of Burger King in assuring patrons they can have it their way?
Apple‘s current Siri capabilities lag significantly behind modern AI chatbot technology, creating a growing competitive disadvantage as users experience more advanced alternatives. Developer Gus Mueller’s suggestion that Apple allow users to choose their own AI assistant represents a pragmatic solution that could benefit both consumers and Apple itself, potentially transforming how voice assistants integrate with Apple’s ecosystem while addressing long-standing complaints about Siri’s limitations.
The big picture: Siri has fallen dramatically behind competing AI technologies, with Apple facing criticism for advertising features that don’t exist and displaying internal disarray over its voice assistant strategy.
- Long-time Apple commentator John Gruber has characterized the situation as a “crisis” for the company, highlighting the significant gap between Siri and modern generative AI capabilities.
- The lack of meaningful progress with Siri has been a persistent issue for approximately a decade, becoming increasingly problematic as alternatives demonstrate far superior capabilities.
A proposed solution: Developer Gus Mueller suggests Apple could allow users to select from various third-party AI models rather than being limited to Siri alone.
- This approach would utilize APIs to connect Apple devices with alternative large language models (LLMs) from providers like ChatGPT, Gemini, Meta, or DeepSeek.
- Users could potentially choose from popular AI models including ChatGPT, Llama, Claude, Gemini, and DeepSeek, dramatically expanding assistant capabilities.
Why this matters: Opening Apple’s ecosystem to third-party AI assistants could create multiple strategic advantages for both users and Apple itself.
- Users would gain immediate access to more capable AI assistants rather than waiting indefinitely for Apple to improve Siri.
- Apple would reduce development pressure on its internal teams while simultaneously gathering valuable data about user preferences and chatbot requests.
- The company could implement granular privacy controls to maintain its privacy-focused brand positioning while embracing external AI capabilities.
Should Apple let us choose our own AI chatbot to replace Siri?