The AI alignment debate has long focused on technical solutions while potentially overlooking the broader societal mechanisms that shape technology adoption and impact. This perspective challenges the current approach to AI alignment by suggesting that external selection processes—how society chooses to adopt, regulate, and integrate AI—may ultimately prove more influential than internal technical solutions alone.
The big picture: The author critiques the narrow technical focus of AI alignment efforts by comparing them to other technologies that society successfully guides through distributed decision-making rather than purely technical solutions.
- The Wikipedia definition of AI alignment—steering AI systems toward intended goals, preferences, or ethical principles—could equally apply to automobiles, pharmaceuticals, or education, yet these don’t have dedicated “alignment” fields.
- While technical AI alignment problems remain important, they represent just a small portion of how society ultimately shapes technology adoption and use.
Key distinction: AI alignment discussions have developed a predominantly technical orientation despite the concept applying broadly to how any technology serves human values.
- The AI Alignment Forum features “more math than Confucius or Foucault,” indicating a preference for technical rather than philosophical or social approaches.
- This contrasts with how society approaches other technologies, where ethical considerations occur largely outside laboratories through purchasing decisions, regulations, and public discourse.
The author’s alternative: The concept of “Selection”—borrowed from evolutionary terminology—describes how society collectively shapes technology through decentralized processes of adoption, regulation, and discussion.
- Selection represents “the sum total of the wills of the masses” as they determine which technologies fill which niches in society.
- This distributed decision-making process is characterized as potentially more important than technical alignment work because it encompasses how AI touches almost everyone despite being a relatively small part of the economy.
Why this matters: The author argues that improving “Selection efficiency” represents the truly significant work of AI alignment that’s currently being overlooked.
- Focusing exclusively on technical solutions while ignoring societal selection mechanisms potentially neglects the most powerful tools for steering AI development.
- Rejecting the importance of selection would mean “giving up on humanity,” as it dismisses the potential for collective action to shape technology for ethical outcomes.
Recent Stories
DOE fusion roadmap targets 2030s commercial deployment as AI drives $9B investment
The Department of Energy has released a new roadmap targeting commercial-scale fusion power deployment by the mid-2030s, though the plan lacks specific funding commitments and relies on scientific breakthroughs that have eluded researchers for decades. The strategy emphasizes public-private partnerships and positions AI as both a research tool and motivation for developing fusion energy to meet data centers' growing electricity demands. The big picture: The DOE's roadmap aims to "deliver the public infrastructure that supports the fusion private sector scale up in the 2030s," but acknowledges it cannot commit to specific funding levels and remains subject to Congressional appropriations. Why...
Oct 17, 2025Tying it all together: Credo’s purple cables power the $4B AI data center boom
Credo, a Silicon Valley semiconductor company specializing in data center cables and chips, has seen its stock price more than double this year to $143.61, following a 245% surge in 2024. The company's signature purple cables, which cost between $300-$500 each, have become essential infrastructure for AI data centers, positioning Credo to capitalize on the trillion-dollar AI infrastructure expansion as hyperscalers like Amazon, Microsoft, and Elon Musk's xAI rapidly build out massive computing facilities. What you should know: Credo's active electrical cables (AECs) are becoming indispensable for connecting the massive GPU clusters required for AI training and inference. The company...
Oct 17, 2025Vatican launches Latin American AI network for human development
The Vatican hosted a two-day conference bringing together 50 global experts to explore how artificial intelligence can advance peace, social justice, and human development. The event launched the Latin American AI Network for Integral Human Development and established principles for ethical AI governance that prioritize human dignity over technological advancement. What you should know: The Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences, the Vatican's research body for social issues, organized the "Digital Rerum Novarum" conference on October 16-17, combining academic research with practical AI applications. Participants included leading experts from MIT, Microsoft, Columbia University, the UN, and major European institutions. The conference...