×
AI Chatbot Controversy Ignites Leadership Turmoil at European Geosciences Union
Written by
Published on
Join our daily newsletter for breaking news, product launches and deals, research breakdowns, and other industry-leading AI coverage
Join Now

A controversy over an AI chatbot developed in China has caused a rift at the European Geosciences Union (EGU), resulting in the firing of its president:

AI chatbot sparks concerns: GeoGPT, an AI-powered chatbot being developed by Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba as part of the Deep-time Digital Earth (DDE) initiative, has raised concerns about transparency, potential state censorship, and copyright infringement:

  • Paul Cleverly, a visiting professor, highlighted “serious issues” with GeoGPT regarding lack of transparency, potential state censorship, and copyright infringement in an editorial.
  • A group of publishers argued that GeoGPT was built off unlicensed literature and lacked transparency by not citing its sources.
  • DDE said it would not make GeoGPT widely available until it could cite sources and is working on a licensing deal with Springer Nature to address concerns.

Tensions at EGU meeting: The controversy came to a head at EGU’s April meeting, where a session introducing GeoGPT was disrupted:

  • EGU’s vice president, Peter van der Beek, reprimanded attendees, ripped up a revised program, and escorted two DDE members out of the room.
  • Several scientists filed complaints about van der Beek’s behavior, claiming it may have constituted harassment and discrimination.
  • Van der Beek apologized to DDE’s president but attendees argue all session participants deserve an apology.

EGU president fired: In May, EGU leaders voted to fire President Irina Artemieva, elevating van der Beek to the role:

  • Artemieva was accused of being difficult to work with, breaching confidentiality by sharing a complainant’s name, and threatening the executive secretary.
  • Supporters argue Artemieva’s confidentiality breach was a mistake and that the firing was a “coup d’état” by the leadership to cover their own mistakes.

Broader context and implications: The episode highlights anxieties around the growing use of AI and China’s rising influence in science:

  • China’s funding of DDE through the $70 million effort is filling a void left by other countries, but some remain wary about the country’s involvement.
  • Models like GeoGPT are becoming more common, with NASA recently announcing its own Earth science AI language model called INDUS.
  • The International Union of Geological Sciences is seeking to broker peace by inviting all parties to a workshop and proposing an international governance body for GeoGPT.
Chinese AI stirs panic at European geoscience society

Recent News

How mathematicians are incorporating AI assistants into their work

AI tools are helping mathematicians develop and verify complex proofs, marking the most significant change in mathematical research methods since computer algebra systems.

Wondering whether to take profits on Nvidia? Jim Cramer offers advice

Early Nvidia investors who held through market swings have seen a single lot of 125 shares grow to 5,000 shares worth millions, highlighting the challenge of balancing profit-taking with maintaining exposure to future growth.

What’s inside ChatGPT’s latest update and why it’s back on top of the AI leaderboards

OpenAI's latest GPT-4 upgrade demonstrates improved file handling and natural language capabilities while maintaining its position ahead of rival models in independent tests.