Robert Downey makes Broadway debut as AI-conflicted novelist

A provocative exploration of AI’s impact on art: Ayad Akhtar’s new play “McNeal” delves into the tension between traditional human creativity and emerging AI technologies, set against the backdrop of a near-future literary world.

• Robert Downey Jr. makes his Broadway debut as Jacob McNeal, a renowned novelist grappling with the encroachment of artificial intelligence on his craft.
• The play, directed by Bartlett Sher, opened at the Vivian Beaumont Theater in Manhattan, transforming the space into a sleek, futuristic setting reminiscent of an Apple store.
• Set in the “very near future,” the story pits computer-mediated interactions against traditional artistic processes, raising questions about the opportunities and challenges presented by AI in creative fields.

Character complexities and controversies: McNeal, as portrayed by Downey Jr., embodies a complex and often unlikable protagonist, challenging audience perceptions and expectations.

• The character is described as a “manly, hard-driving literary novelist of the old school,” drawing comparisons to figures like Saul Bellow or Philip Roth.
• However, McNeal comes across as whiny, entitled, and fatuous rather than magnetic and personable, creating a disconnect between the character’s description and his actual portrayal.
• The play explores McNeal’s flaws, including his vanity, flirtatious nature, and obliviousness to moral implications, presenting them as part of his persona.

Controversial elements and social commentary: “McNeal” incorporates provocative themes and dialogue, touching on sensitive topics related to diversity and political correctness.

• The protagonist aggressively asserts his anti-woke stance, engaging in potentially offensive behavior and dialogue.
• In one scene, McNeal asks a Black New York Times journalist if she was a “diversity hire,” demonstrating his lack of social awareness and sensitivity.
• These elements contribute to the play’s exploration of generational and ideological divides in the literary world and broader society.

Critiques and limitations: While “McNeal” presents timely themes, it faces challenges in its execution and dramatic impact.

• The review suggests that the play works better as a provocation than as a fully realized drama.
• Characters, including McNeal, are described as more akin to data sets or ideas rather than credible human beings.
• The play’s focus on concepts and debates about technology sometimes overshadows character development and emotional engagement.

Technological integration and symbolism: The production incorporates AI elements both thematically and practically, blurring the lines between human and machine creativity.

• An opening scene features McNeal interacting with ChatGPT, attempting to determine his chances of winning the Nobel Prize.
• The set design, with its sleek and futuristic aesthetics, serves as a visual metaphor for the encroachment of technology on traditional artistic spaces.
• The play’s structure and themes reflect current anxieties about AI’s role in creative industries and human expression.

Broadway debut and star power: Robert Downey Jr.’s presence adds significant attention to the production, marking a notable transition from his film career to the stage.

• This performance represents Downey Jr.’s Broadway debut, bringing his considerable fame and talent to the theater world.
• The casting choice adds weight to the exploration of the tension between established, traditional figures (represented by McNeal) and emerging technologies.

Broader implications for art and technology: “McNeal” serves as a catalyst for discussions about the future of creativity in an increasingly AI-driven world.

• The play raises questions about the value of human artistry in the face of advancing AI capabilities.
• It explores the potential loss of certain human qualities in art as technology becomes more prevalent in creative processes.
• By presenting a flawed and controversial protagonist, the play challenges audiences to consider the complexities of artistic genius and its place in a changing technological landscape.